Asheville Police Department Pushes to Expand Panhandling Restrictions

City panhandling restrictions debate

Asheville Police Department Pushes to Expand Panhandling Restrictions

Asheville, North Carolina

Overview

After a 10-month hiatus, the Asheville city government has resumed discussions on panhandling restrictions. Asheville Police Chief Mike Lamb is pushing to increase the number of places designated as High Traffic Zones where panhandling is prohibited, despite a decline in calls reporting panhandlers.

Data Analysis

Despite data showing a 40% decrease in panhandling calls over the last year, Lamb argues that more restrictions are necessary for safety reasons. The decrease in calls is attributed to underreporting or staffing issues.

Safety Concerns

Lamb presented data linking panhandling to pedestrian crashes, with one out of every five occurring near a reported panhandling location. Council members questioned the validity of the data presented, raising concerns about causation.

Proposed Changes

Lamb recommended additional High Traffic Zones in areas like Patton Avenue and S. Tunnel Road. The existing zone in downtown Asheville may also be expanded to include sections of Merrimon Avenue and the South Slope.

Constitutional Issues

Panhandling is protected under the First Amendment, but Asheville has existing ordinances regulating certain aspects of panhandling. City attorney Brad Branham believes current regulations are consistent with State and Federal law.

Community Perspective

Some members of the homeless community believe safety concerns are being used as an excuse to push them out. Tourism is seen as a driving factor in the enforcement of panhandling regulations.

Previous Discussions

Last September, Asheville City Council updated the panhandling ordinance with technical amendments. Proposals for new High Traffic Zones and a ban on vehicle donations were considered but faced public backlash.

Current Status

While no ordinance changes have been made, discussions will continue at the council level if any updates are proposed. The city awaits further direction from the governing body.