Buncombe Planning Board Postpones Vote on STR Regulations Amid Growing Concerns of Misinformation

Buncombe Planning Board Postpones Vote on STR Regulations

Amid Growing Concerns of Misinformation

The Buncombe County Planning Board has decided to delay a crucial vote on proposed regulations for short-term vacation rentals (STRs) following a wave of what some members are calling “misinformation” and “propaganda” surrounding the issue. The board’s decision comes in the midst of heated public hearings on the matter, with tensions running high on both sides of the debate.

The “No Ban for Buncombe” Campaign

At the center of the controversy is the “No Ban for Buncombe” campaign, which is funded by various organizations. The campaign, with the slogan “Don’t Kill Our Economy,” has been actively advocating against proposed regulations on STRs through various means such as mail, online platforms, and television advertisements.

According to Chip Craig, Chair of the STR Trust, the campaign is aimed at providing accurate data and facts to the public. However, some board members and community activists have raised concerns about the validity of the information being circulated.

Debating the Impact of STRs on Housing

While Buncombe County’s proposed regulations include certain measures, proponents argue that these are necessary to address housing affordability and community cohesion issues. Chris Joyell of Mountain True pointed to a significant housing gap in the county and emphasized the need for a balanced approach to STRs to alleviate pressure on the housing market.

On the other hand, supporters of the “No Ban for Buncombe” campaign argue that the proposed regulations would essentially amount to a ban on future STRs in the county. They contend that the impact of STRs on housing prices is overstated and that regulations are not the sole solution to addressing housing affordability.

A Complex Economic Landscape

As the debate rages on, various studies and reports have been cited by both sides to support their claims. While some argue that the increased presence of STRs leads to a decrease in long-term rental units, others suggest that there is no significant correlation between STRs and home prices in the region.

Nick Hinton, President of the Land of Sky Association of Realtors, defended the campaign as a reflection of the membership’s interests and highlighted the importance of conducting studies on the impact of STRs in the area. Real estate agents have also weighed in on the debate, with some focusing on selling second homes as investments for potential short-term rentals.

Seeking Common Ground

Despite the diverging viewpoints on the issue, there is a growing consensus among community activists and board members that a collaborative approach is needed to address the complex interplay between housing, tourism, and economic development. In light of the postponement of the vote, stakeholders are hopeful that a task force can be established to facilitate constructive dialogue and ensure that decisions are made based on accurate and comprehensive information.

As Buncombe County grapples with the ongoing debate over STR regulations, the need for transparency, accountability, and community engagement remains paramount. It is clear that finding common ground on this contentious issue will require a concerted effort from all parties involved.